What a Pathological Clause Is and Why the Question Arises
A pathological arbitration clause is one drafted defectively — for example, it prescribes an unclear mechanism for appointing arbitrators or names an institution that does not exist. The Law of Georgia on Arbitration answers such situations with dedicated mechanisms: Article 6 establishes the independence of arbitration and the prohibition of court intervention, Article 16 empowers the tribunal to rule on its own jurisdiction, and Article 24 fills procedural gaps. These three provisions are examined in detail below, together with the practical situations in which they operate.
Independence of Arbitration and the Ban on Court Intervention
Article 6 lays the foundation of the system: in its activities the arbitration is independent and follows the procedure of the arbitral proceedings determined by the parties or by the arbitration, in compliance with the requirements of the law. Any intervention by a court in the legal relationships provided for by the law is impermissible, except in cases directly provided for by the law. This means that a defect in the clause does not automatically transfer the case to a court — the court reacts only in the situations directly specified by statute.
The classic scenario of pathology arises where the clause invokes a mechanism for the appointment of arbitrators that in practice does not work when the parties disagree, or where the conditions listed in the clause contradict one another. The question then splits in two: may arbitral proceedings be commenced at all because of this, and who should decide that question. It is precisely these two questions that Articles 16 and 24 of the law answer.
Kompetenz-Kompetenz — the Tribunal Rules on Its Own Jurisdiction
Under Article 16 the tribunal is empowered to rule on its own jurisdiction, including determining the existence or authenticity of the arbitration agreement. For this purpose an arbitration clause that forms part of a contract is treated as an independent arbitration agreement — a ruling that the contract is null and void does not entail the invalidity of the clause. This doctrine, resting on the separability of the clause from the contract, is the principal tool for dealing with pathological clauses: problems with other terms of the contract do not deprive the arbitration of jurisdiction. A decision on jurisdiction is taken before the final award or together with it, and where the parties have agreed otherwise, the tribunal takes the decision in accordance with their agreement.










