Clearance Appeals involves the specific legal process of challenging the refusal, suspension, or revocation of the right (clearance) to work with state secrets for an individual or legal entity. Security clearance is essential not only for employees of law enforcement agencies but also for private companies and contractors involved in defense and security procurement. Refusal of clearance is often based on the results of vetting by the State Security Service (SUS), which may be subjective or based on inaccurate information. Without clearance, an individual may lose their job, and a company may lose its license or the right to participate in tenders. Therefore, verifying the legality of the refusal and appealing it is critically important for protecting professional activities and business interests.
What does the Clearance Appeals service cover?
Legal.ge specialists offer full legal support in the complex appeals process:
- Analysis of grounds for refusal: Legal assessment of the official reasons for refusal or revocation of clearance (compliance with the law).
- Preparation of administrative complaint: Drafting and submitting a complaint to a superior administrative body (e.g., the Head of SUS).
- Court representation: Defending interests in court, including compliance with rules for secret proceedings.
- Reputation protection: Refuting negative conclusions based on erroneous information and restoring the client's credibility.
- Evidence collection: Obtaining alternative evidence confirming the client's trustworthiness and compliance with security requirements.
Common scenarios and issues
Appealing clearance decisions is often related to the following situations:
- Public servant: An official was denied promotion or dismissed because they failed the vetting for "Secret" level information access.
- Defense contractor: A construction or IT company had its clearance suspended due to alleged security violations, causing it to lose a government contract.
- Biographical inaccuracies: The vetting revealed an old, expunged criminal record or incorrect information about relatives, which became the basis for refusal.
- Security regime violation: An individual was stripped of clearance due to allegations of mishandling classified information, which they wish to appeal as unfounded.
Georgian Legislation and Appeal Rules
The process is regulated by the Law of Georgia on State Secrets, which defines the criteria for granting and revoking clearance. The appeal procedure is based on the General Administrative Code of Georgia (administrative complaint) and the Administrative Procedure Code (court dispute). It is important to know that disputes related to state secrets are often heard in closed sessions. A lawyer participating in such a case may need special clearance or a non-disclosure agreement themselves. The law requires the refusal to be substantiated, but due to security interests, part of the information may be classified even for the applicant, which complicates the defense.
Process Stages
- Consultation: The lawyer reviews the formal reasons for the refusal.
- Strategy: Determining the appeal tactics—administrative or judicial route.
- Filing the complaint: Submitting a legally substantiated complaint within the relevant timeframe (usually 1 month).
- Hearing: Participating in the dispute hearing and presenting the client's arguments.
Why turn to Legal.ge?
Security clearance cases require specific experience and in-depth knowledge of administrative law. A standard civil lawyer may not be able to handle the specifics of security services. Legal.ge gives you access to lawyers who have practical experience in such cases and know how to protect client rights against the state machine while maintaining high standards of confidentiality.
Updated: ...