Smart contract legal review: when and why
A smart contract legal review differs from conducting a dispute: it is an analysis carried out before a dispute — or within one — that answers the question of what the code does legally and whether this corresponds to the parties' intended agreement. Georgia has no separate rule for this — the expertise institution of the Civil Procedure Code applies, regulating technical assessment before the court.
The need for expertise arises in two typical situations. The first — preventive: the parties check the contract before release so that a dispute does not arise at all. The second — judicial: during a dispute the court resorts to special knowledge, because interpreting the code's behaviour without it is impossible. In both cases the form and content of the expertise are determined by procedural norms.
The appointment and conduct of the expertise
Under Article 162, where a judge lacks special knowledge on a question connected with the examination of a case, the court may, on its own initiative, appoint an expertise, if the interpretation of the question has essential significance and a decision cannot be made without it. The parties may also independently ensure the conduct of an expertise and submit the conclusion at the stage of the initiation or preparation of the case.
Article 166 regulates conduct in a special expert institution: the court sends the institution its ruling and the necessary materials; the head of the institution entrusts the expertise to one or several employees and explains to them their rights, duties and responsibility; the written undertaking is sent to the court together with the conclusion. Article 167 regulates conduct in a non-special institution: there the expert is appointed by the court itself, which verifies his speciality and competence and warns him about responsibility.
The form and content of the conclusion
Under Article 170, the expert gives the conclusion in written form; the court has the right to propose that the expert give an oral explanation, which is entered into the minutes of the hearing. The conclusion must contain a written description of the investigation conducted, the conclusions obtained and substantiated answers to the questions posed by the court.
For smart contract expertise this requirement is decisive: the precise posing of the questions — by what logic the code operated, which condition was activated, whether another result was possible — determines the value of the conclusion. A correctly posed question frees the expert from inventing the task; an incorrectly posed one makes the answer meaningless.

