Why Market Valuation Is the Decisive Step
In enforcement proceedings, property placed under seizure is realized by auction, and the success of the auction — and the balance between the parties' interests — depends largely on how accurately the market value of the property has been determined, since the starting price is based on it. An undervaluation prejudices the creditor and reduces the prospect of full satisfaction; an inflated valuation makes the property unsellable and delays the procedure. This stage is governed by Article 47 (assessment of seized property) and Article 48 (the act of description and seizure) of the Georgian Law on Enforcement Proceedings.
This page describes when and by whom the assessment is carried out, what role is played by an expert conclusion submitted by a party to the proceedings, and what the act of description and seizure — the document that records the results of the assessment and becomes the basis for subsequent challenges — must contain.
How Seized Property Is Assessed
Under the first paragraph of Article 47, at the time of the description of the property, where it is possible to determine its market value, that value is recorded in the act of description and seizure. If determining the prices at the description is impossible, the property is assessed after the registration of the seizure by the National Bureau of Enforcement or by another competent person commissioned by the Bureau. This applies where the nature, condition or market specifics of the item do not allow its value to be fixed immediately at the moment of description.
In cases of tax arrears an additional rule operates: on the basis of an agreement between the National Bureau of Enforcement and the tax authority, when property of a taxpayer is assessed for the purposes of securing the collection of tax arrears, a repeated assessment of that property in the enforcement proceedings is not mandatory if the assessment of the property to be realized was carried out within 1 year before the commencement of the enforcement proceedings. This means that in certain tax cases an earlier assessment continues to be used, saving both time and expense.
The Expert Conclusion and the Parties' Rights
The fourth paragraph of Article 47 gives a party to the enforcement proceedings the right, at the commencement of the proceedings or before the Bureau assesses the property, to submit an expert conclusion on the determination of the property's market value, under which the property was assessed within 6 months before the commencement of the enforcement proceedings. The Bureau is entitled to rely on the conclusion submitted by a party, and where conclusions on the same property have been submitted by both parties — on one of the conclusions. The question of whether it is expedient to deem a conclusion admissible is decided by the National Bureau of Enforcement.
This is precisely where practical disputes arise: the creditor does not want the property undervalued, while the debtor does not want it carried off for less than it is worth. If a party considers that the Bureau's assessment does not reflect the real market value, the timely submission of its own expert conclusion is the instrument provided by law; any refusal to rely on it must be justified by the Bureau as a matter of expediency.

