Copyright Disputes

Royalty Disputes

Who owns the economic rights in a commissioned work?

The commissioning party, unless the contract provides otherwise.

What is undistributed royalty?

Royalty that could not be distributed within 3 years from the end of the financial year of collection; its use is decided by the general meeting.

How does the law protect the author in the contract?

It voids restrictions on future creativity and the transfer of rights in future works as the contract's subject.

What does the organization owe unidentified holders?

Publication on its website within 3 months of expiry about such works, and safekeeping of the sums in a separate account.

5 min·9 Jan 2026

Royalty Disputes — Sources and Routes to Resolution

A royalty dispute always depends on the source from which the money flows: where the royalty runs directly between the commissioning party and the author, the dispute is governed by Articles 43 and 44 of the Law on Copyright and Neighbouring Rights — the rules of the commissioning contract and the obligation to compensate damage; and where the sum moves through a collective-management organization, the dispute is resolved under the collection and distribution rules of Article 66-2. This page explains both circuits.

The Commissioning Contract and the Royalty — Article 43

Under a work-creation contract the author undertakes to create a work according to the terms of the contract and to transfer it to the commissioning party, while the latter undertakes to accept the work and pay the author a royalty. The author must create the work personally unless the contract provides otherwise; the involvement of another person is admissible only with the commissioning party's consent. The commissioning party must examine the work as soon as the contractual term arrives and notify the author in writing of acceptance, rejection or the need for corrections — and if no written notice is sent within the term, the work is deemed accepted.

Additional royalty-related rules matter as well: the procedure, term and amount of the advance are defined by the contract. Void is any contract clause restricting the author's right to create, in the future, a work on a defined topic or in a defined field, and the subject of the contract cannot be the transfer of rights in a work to be created in the future. The economic rights in a work created on commission belong to the commissioning party unless the contract provides otherwise — the terms of the royalty and the fate of the rights are thus decided by a single document, and it is exactly this document that must be drafted precisely.

The Price of Breach — Article 44

Where a party failed to perform or improperly performed an obligation under a contract of transfer of economic rights, creation of a work or a licence, it must compensate the other party for the damage caused, including lost income. This norm is the central instrument of the royalty dispute: an unpaid royalty is treated as damage, and the claim against it is built on exactly this basis.