The Procedural Foundations of DNA Evidence
DNA analysis is among the most influential forms of evidence in criminal cases, yet its power depends entirely on whether the procedural rules governing the taking, storage, transfer and evaluation of samples were observed. The Criminal Procedure legislation regulates this chain through several norms: the taking of biological samples during inspection of the corpse, the grounds for appointing an expert examination, the rules for the object of expert research, and the requirements for the expert's conclusion. Mastery of these norms is where the defence and the prosecution gain or lose their advantage.
Article 128 regulates the inspection of the corpse: the external inspection is conducted by a party with the participation of an expert. For an unidentified corpse, dactyloscopic examination and the taking of a sample for expert research — including the taking of a biological sample and the storage of the genetic profile in the DNA database — are mandatory. In a case involving an unidentified body, the collection of biological material is therefore not a choice but a statutory duty, and its omission is itself a procedural defect the defence can invoke.
Grounds for Appointing an Examination
The governing rule is Article 144: an expert examination is conducted where, without the participation of experts in an appropriate field of science, technology, art or craft, it is impossible to establish factual circumstances significant for the case, and also where a trace, sign or feature significant for the case is observed on a body or an object containing information, whose correct understanding and perception is impossible without specialised knowledge. DNA research falls squarely within this category — interpreting a genetic profile demands specialised knowledge.
An examination is conducted on a party's initiative. If the object of the expert research is kept with the other party, that party is obliged to hand the object over to the expert of the initiating party. Where a party cannot obtain the object voluntarily, it may apply to the court at the place of the investigation with a motion for the transfer of the object to the expert. Such a motion must be examined no later than 48 hours, and the court's ruling is not subject to appeal. If the author of the motion fails to appear, the motion is not examined — a trap for the unprepared litigant.
Defence-Initiated Examinations and Protection of the Object
Amendments to the Code granted the defence significant guarantees. Where the expert of the initiating party failed to ensure, or did not ensure, the protection of the object of the expert research, the expert's conclusion is inadmissible evidence, and the questioning of the expert as a witness is likewise inadmissible. This is a severe sanction for a broken chain of custody: storing a DNA sample without proper protection directly strips the conclusion of legal force.
The defence may, after the transfer to an expert of an object obtained through its own motion within a primary investigation, require the expert to determine the possibility of conducting the examination repeatedly. Where the object is consumable or subject to destruction, or where this cannot be determined, the expert must immediately notify the prosecution, which in turn must immediately notify the defence. From that moment the defence may submit written questions to the prosecution within a period of 3 days from receipt of the notice, and the prosecution must immediately forward them to the expert.

