Appeals & Post-Conviction

Innocence Projects

What does an acquittal mean?

The failure to prove the charge; its text may not contain formulations excluding the innocence of the acquitted person.

Is the review time limit restricted?

On newly discovered circumstances it is unlimited, except where the application rests on an international decision — then within 1 year.

Who reopens a judgment built on forged evidence?

The appellate court through the review procedure, where the forgery is established by another judgment in legal force.

Is examination without an oral hearing possible?

Yes, the appellate court is entitled to examine the case without an oral hearing.

4 min·9 Jan 2026

The Acquittal and Its Content

Under the Criminal Procedure Code, an acquittal means the failure to prove the charge brought against the accused. The second part of the same norm sets a special qualitative requirement: an acquittal must not contain formulations that exclude the innocence of the acquitted person or are dishonoring to his or her name. This means that a court cannot say "the prosecution was not proven, but he probably did it" — the text of the judgment must not be burdened with assessments incompatible with innocence. The road to proving innocence begins precisely from this standard: when a person is acquitted, the restoration of his or her name is not only a procedural result but also a reputational act. In practice the violation of this norm often appears in the reasoning of the judgment, where the court underlines the suspiciousness of the accusation with superfluous assessments. Challenging and excluding such formulations is one of the tasks of the defence of the acquitted, because the text of the judgment is a public document that accompanies a person's later life for a long time.

Grounds for Review of a Judgment

The Code defines a complete catalogue of grounds for the review of a judgment on newly discovered circumstances. A judgment is reviewed where: a judgment in legal force has established that the evidence on which the judgment under review was based is forged; a circumstance exists attesting the unlawful composition of the court that delivered the judgment or the inadmissibility of the evidence; it has been established that the judge, prosecutor, investigator or juror committed a crime in connection with this case; the Constitutional Court has declared the criminal law applied in this case unconstitutional; the European Court of Human Rights or a respective committee of the United Nations has found a violation of a convention on which the judgment under review rests; a new law has abolished or mitigated liability; a new fact or evidence has been presented that was unknown at the time of the judgment and proves the innocence of the convicted person; likewise the prosecutor's decision on an essential violation of rights or the ruling of the appellate court recognizing a covert investigative action as unlawful. The ground of a new fact or evidence is two-directional: it may prove the innocence of the convicted person or the commission of a lesser crime, but equally the guilt of an acquitted person — the instrument of review thus serves both defence and prosecution. The list of grounds is exhaustively defined, and a demand beyond its limits is inadmissible, which makes the selection of the correct ground the threshold of the whole process.