Construction Contracts

Construction Dispute Resolution

When may I terminate the contract because of a flaw?

Because of a defect of the product the customer may refuse the contract under Article 405 of the Code, and in that case the contractor must reimburse the expenses connected with the contract.

How does the reduction of the remuneration work?

The customer who neither receives supplementary performance after the determined period nor refuses the contract may reduce the remuneration by the amount by which the defect reduces the value of the product.

What periods apply to defect claims?

A defect claim may be brought within one year, and one concerning a structure within five years from acceptance. With acceptance in parts the period begins from complete acceptance. Under the general regime, contractual claims carry three years and claims connected with immovables six years.

What does the customer demand under a contract for work?

The contractor undertakes to perform the envisaged work and the customer must pay the agreed remuneration. Ownership of a thing produced from the contractor's material passes to the customer.

5 min·9 Jan 2026

Construction Dispute Resolution: Choosing the Remedy

Resolving a construction dispute begins not at the courthouse door but with the question of which legal remedy the customer should choose: termination of the contract, a demand of supplementary performance, or a reduction of the remuneration. The rules of the contract for work in the Civil Code place this choice in a clear frame and set their own conditions and periods for each path. The right choice depends on the character of the flaw, the possibility of curing it, and whether the work retains value for the customer.

The Frame of the Contract for Work

Every remedy is built on the basic construction of the contract for work. Under Article 629 of the Civil Code, by a contract for work the contractor undertakes to perform the work envisaged by the contract, while the customer must pay the contractor the agreed remuneration. Where the work includes the production of a thing from material procured by the contractor, the contractor transfers to the customer ownership of the produced thing, and where a generic thing is produced the rules of sale apply. The preparation of an estimate connected with the work is not reimbursed unless otherwise agreed. This frame determines what the customer demands at all and which condition connects to which remedy.

Termination Because of a Defect

The most radical remedy is termination. Under Article 644 of the Civil Code, because of a defect of the product the customer may refuse the contract in accordance with Article 405 of the Code. In this case the contractor must reimburse the customer's expenses connected with the contract. Termination is justified where the flaw is such that even a corrected work no longer satisfies the customer's interest, and choosing this path often requires observing the rules on the additional period.

Reduction of the Remuneration as an Alternative

Where the work remains usable, the middle path is a reduction of the remuneration. Under Article 645 of the Civil Code, the customer who neither receives supplementary performance after expiry of the period determined for that purpose nor declares refusal of the contract may reduce the remuneration by the amount by which the defect reduces the value of the product. This claim is flexible: it preserves the relationship and at the same time aligns the price with the actual quality.